Information for Buyers 

In specific scenarios, sellers may find themselves in a situation where they receive multiple competing purchase offers for their property. Sellers have several options for how to handle these various offers. They can accept the best offer they receive, inform all potential buyers that multiple offers are being considered, and invite them to submit their best proposals, counter one offer while setting aside the others for further consideration, or counter one offer and reject the others outright.

Although the listing broker can provide advice and suggestions, it's essential to understand that the seller makes final decisions regarding handling these offers, not the listing broker.

Different negotiation strategies have pros and cons in multiple offer situations. For instance, a lower initial offer could result in acquiring the property for less than the listed price. However, it might also lead to losing the property if another buyer submits a higher offer. Conversely, offering the total listing price might secure the property but could mean paying more than necessary. Additionally, multiple full-price offers could compete for the seller's attention and acceptance. Buyer representatives will explain these various negotiation strategies to buyers, but it's important to remember that the ultimate decisions rest with the buyers themselves.

It's worth noting that purchase offers are typically not kept confidential. Sometimes, sellers may inform other buyers that they have received a request or even share details of an offer to encourage better recommendations. Sellers may instruct their listing broker to make such disclosures on their behalf. While some real estate professionals may hesitate to disclose offer terms, there are usually no prohibitions against it in the Code of Ethics. However, state laws or real estate regulations may restrict brokers from disclosing offers to third parties. Buyers may consider discussing the possibility of keeping their offer confidential or establishing a confidentiality agreement with the seller before starting negotiations.

Buyer representatives often have multiple buyer clients, some of whom might be interested in the same properties. Buyers should discuss with their representatives how offers and counter-offers will be presented and negotiated if multiple clients pursue the same property. Finally, it's crucial to understand that the advice provided by a buyer representative is based on their experience and expertise. Still, it only guarantees how a particular seller will respond in a specific situation.

Information for Sellers

As a seller, if you find yourself with multiple competing offers for your property, your listing broker can explain various negotiation strategies to consider. These options include accepting the best offer, informing all potential buyers about multiple offers and inviting them to submit their best offers, countering one offer while setting aside the others for later consideration, or countering one offer while rejecting the others.

Each of these approaches has its advantages and disadvantages. For instance, exercising patience may result in a better offer, while inviting buyers to submit their best offers could lead to higher bids and discourage some buyers. Your listing broker will provide insights into these strategies, but the final decisions rest with you, the seller. It's important to note that your listing broker's advice is based on their experience but does not guarantee how a specific buyer will act or react in a given situation.

Information for Buyers and Sellers

Navigating multiple competing offers can be a complex and frustrating experience for buyers and sellers. Sellers aim to get the best price and terms for their property, while buyers seek the lowest price and favorable terms. Listing brokers represent sellers' interests, while buyer representatives advocate for their clients.

Decisions made by sellers, such as disclosing information about one buyer's offer, can influence whether another buyer makes a full-price offer or looks elsewhere. Similarly, inviting buyers to submit their best offers can create intense competition or deter buyers who feel their initial offer was fair.

While there is no single, straightforward way to handle multiple competing offers, some fundamental principles can simplify the process. Both listing brokers and buyer representatives are bound by state real estate regulations and, if applicable, the Code of Ethics of the National Association of REALTORS®. This code obligates real estate professionals to be honest with all parties, present offers, and counter-offers promptly and objectively, and cooperate with other brokers by sharing relevant information.

Misunderstandings can arise when cooperating brokers are unaware of the status of offers they have presented. Listing brokers should make reasonable efforts to keep buyer representatives informed about offer statuses, and buyer representatives should reciprocate by updating listing brokers on counter-offers made by their seller-clients.

In multiple offer situations, only one offer will result in a sale, often disappointing other buyers. While it's challenging to alleviate that disappointment entirely, treating all buyers fairly and honestly throughout the negotiation process, coupled with open communication, can enhance the perception of fairness among all parties involved.

Shoot us an email at jill@jillbiggsgroup.com or give us a call at (973) 495-6038!